www.outdoorbits.com

Sister shop to Motorhome Facts TomTom GO LIVE Camper & Caravan
TomTom GO LIVE Camper & Caravan

The ultimate Sat Nav system for your motorhome, pre-programmed with 20,000+ POI's from the largest European Motorhoming Websites including the Motorhome Facts Campsite Database.

Motorhome Insurance

motorhome insurance quote online
Phone on 0208 9845311

Motorhome Insurance Quote

Campsite Reviews

The Woodbridge Inn  Review Photo

Review of The Woodbridge Inn

UK Campsite UK

Full Details

Motorhome Garage

2005 Wildax Constellation
2005 Wildax Constellation motorhome
Owned by Chris_s
Updated 09/10/2009

2008 Rapido 7090
2008 Rapido 7090 motorhome
Owned by rayc
Updated 21/10/2011

2008 Carthargo Chic T47
2008 Carthargo Chic T47 motorhome
Owned by gandj
Updated 29/12/2008

Motorhome Chat Rooms

Motorhome Chat

10 Chat Rooms
0 Members connected
0 members chatting

Chat Now

Motorhome Facts :: View topic - Alde Vs Truma

Advertise Here
Welcome to Motorhomefacts, we are a thriving motorhome community (Largest in Europe). Why Not JOIN NOW and get instant access to more of the website. It costs nothing to join and only takes a few minutes.
We have 200,000 different people visiting our site monthly and this amount of motorhomers in one place guarantees a fast response to any questions you may have. We also have unique facilities not found elsewhere such as our Online Logbook, stopover tracker, Motorhome directory with Ebay type feedback and the largest repository of motorhome campsites reviews found anywhere



Rally News Next Rally is @ Spring Bank Holiday at Hamble Primary School, Hamble, Southampton on 01/06/2012 in Hampshire

Tweet This Topic Facebook del.icio.us digg blogmarks Furl Reddit technorati Yahoo Google Chatting:  Chat Now View previous topic View next topic

Post new topic Reply to topic Printer-friendly version

 
1188235 Post Posted: Sat Jan 21, 2012 6:45 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

dipsie Subscriber 14/11/2012 


Age: 67

Joined: May 30, 2008

Posts: 32

MH: Swift 680FB

Campsites

Gender: Male

Location: Somerset

england.gif

Status: Offline

Clayton, we have a Swift Belero 680FB and we have a 6Kg and a 11Kg Gaslow systen fitted, it was a tight fit, you have to fit the 11Kg first, but it is possible. We have looked at the new Bolero but to change our's which is'nt three years old yet and only done 11,000 miles our dealer wanted Ģ20,000, I think we will put up with the blown air. Bernie T
 
1199862 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 10:42 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

statenisland Subscriber 08/09/2012 


Joined: Aug 17, 2007

Posts: 93

MH: looking

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Status: Offline

Good evening,

I am considering buying the new Bolero 724FB and looked at the Alde website for more information on the heating system.

It states a 6kg gas bottle should last a weekend - that seems a lot of gas. Can anybody confirm this high usage?
It also says the temperature should be maintained at 10 degrees at all times - why? Can anybody explain?
It says too that LPG is not suitable due to additives. Is there any reason?

Thanks

Brian
 
1199874 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:00 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

MyGalSal Subscriber 15/12/2012 


Joined: Dec 08, 2008

Posts: 669

MH: Hymer B694SL

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Location: Europe

uk.gif

Status: Offline

6kg does seem like a lot of gas for a weekend! I think it would last you easily a week - even in very cold temps.

Alde does use more gas than Truma but it is a much more effective method of heating. It is brilliant.

Can't think why it mentions 10 degrees. The only thing I can think at the moment is that somewhere I have read there is a factory default setting (which we have switched off!)for heating at some time in order to combat Legionaires thingy.

We have Gaslow and fill up with LPG at all the usual places and have no problems at all. I haven't heard of anyone else having problems either.

Go for the Alde. It is brilliant!

Sal

______________________________________________________________
If you donīt know where you are going when you set off you will probably end up somewhere different!
 LPG
1199879 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:12 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

teemyob Linked Subscriber 26/07/2012 


Joined: Nov 22, 2005

Posts: 11983

MH: Mercedes V6 Frankia I8400GD-RLC + Sprinter 311 Self Build Project

Campsites

Gender: Male

Location: Cheshire

blank.gif

Status: Offline

statenisland wrote:
Good evening,

I am considering buying the new Bolero 724FB and looked at the Alde website for more information on the heating system.

It states a 6kg gas bottle should last a weekend - that seems a lot of gas. Can anybody confirm this high usage?
It also says the temperature should be maintained at 10 degrees at all times - why? Can anybody explain?
It says too that LPG is not suitable due to additives. Is there any reason?

Thanks

Brian


LPG is Calor, Butane or Propane as well as all the other refillable bottles.

Do you mean Autogas?

TM
 
1199881 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:13 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

Glandwr Subscriber 22/06/2012 


Joined: Jun 12, 2006

Posts: 4158

MH: Hymer S740

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Location: The Berwyn mountains

wales.gif

Status: Offline

We have both. Wet and blown air. Wet is by far the best and is best if you have sinus probs BUT does take quite a while for the van to reach a good temp.

I've not noticed a discernable difference in gas consumption but am convinced the wet system uses less battery power.

Dick

______________________________________________________________
Powys, Paradwys Cymru

"Rules are for the guidance of wise men and the obedience of fools." Douglas Bader CBE
 Autogas
1199882 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:14 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

teemyob Linked Subscriber 26/07/2012 


Joined: Nov 22, 2005

Posts: 11983

MH: Mercedes V6 Frankia I8400GD-RLC + Sprinter 311 Self Build Project

Campsites

Gender: Male

Location: Cheshire

blank.gif

Status: Offline

From the ALDE website

"Autogas is a blend of propane/butane, and the ratio varies greatly across Europe. Although UK Autogas is mostly propane it also contains additives that may make it unsuitable for use in Alde system."

But some converters do fit ALDE and LPG Bulk Tanks!

TM
 
1199885 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:17 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

selstrom Subscriber 12/09/2012 


Joined: May 23, 2005

Posts: 78

MH: Concorde

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Status: Offline

We have used our ALDE system for 5 years on LPG with no problem.
The amount of gas used by both systems will be very similar as I suspect both boilers efficiency are very similar. The main factors affecting gas usage are the vehicle size, degree of insulation and temperature difference between outside and inside. Having a engine heat exchanger will obviously reduce gas use.

Unless one uses Red Diesel the cost of using a deisel heater will be a lot higher than gas as it costs twice as much but only contains 1.5 times the energy of gas.
 
1199896 Post Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 11:38 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

selstrom Subscriber 12/09/2012 


Joined: May 23, 2005

Posts: 78

MH: Concorde

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Status: Offline

"Alde does use more gas than Truma but it is a much more effective method of heating. It is brilliant."

What evidence is there for Alde system using more gas than Truma?

Our motorhome is an 8.5m A class and if it is cold you can easily use 2 to 3 lt a day, we run our heating for 24 hours though the temperature at night is reduced to 17.
 
1199916 Post Posted: Mon Feb 13, 2012 12:17 am Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

MyGalSal Subscriber 15/12/2012 


Joined: Dec 08, 2008

Posts: 669

MH: Hymer B694SL

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Location: Europe

uk.gif

Status: Offline

I don't have any actual evidence that Alde uses more gas than Truma, only an awareness that we need to fill up more often than when we had Truma - taking the usual varying factors into account.

As has already been said, it uses less battery - that I can measure more accurately because of the panel.

Sal

Edit: in my comparison of Alde/Truma I am basing it on the Alde in our current van, a Hymer 694 which is 7.3m with a double floor and double glazed cab windows and the Truma in our previous van a Hymer 654 which was 7m with a single floor and no double glazing.

______________________________________________________________
If you donīt know where you are going when you set off you will probably end up somewhere different!
 
1200034 Post Posted: Mon Feb 13, 2012 12:57 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote Back To Top

statenisland Subscriber 08/09/2012 


Joined: Aug 17, 2007

Posts: 93

MH: looking

Campsites

Gender: None specified

Status: Offline

Good morning,

Thanks for all the replies.

Teemyob - I would be obliged if you would give me the heads up regarding LPG/Autogas. I assumed Gaslow/other refillable cylinder owners filled up at petrol stations(in UK and Europe) using the same pump that gas powered cars used and therefore ran their MH heating off Autogas.

Clayton9 - Have you been able to ascertain if Swift are fitting an engine heat exchanger to the Alde system?

Brian
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Members do not see the Adverts Below
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum
All times are GMT + 1 Hour  
Page 3 of 4  
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next


Post new topic Reply to topic Printer-friendly version

Tweet This Topic Facebook del.icio.us digg blogmarks Furl Reddit technorati Yahoo Google Go to MAIN SITE Front Page