You are a Guest, please Join now to allow full access to the website and be part of our community. You can register by clicking the "Click Here to create an account" link at the top left of the page under our Logo
Anyone have any experience of this type of TV aerial for Freeview reception? >>
Only registered users can see links on our Forum Join Now or Login
<<
We dont watch a huge amount of TV so was tempted with a magnetic base aerial that we could bung on the roof as and when required, and not have to drill big holes in the van.
Thanks alot.
Steve
The following members of MHF thanked b6x for this posting
I think that this is unlikely to work in most camp sites. The signal strength is often quite low.
You need a directional broadband aerial. A good amplifier helps. But if the signal in is rubbish no amplifier can improve it.
With digital I have found that low cost amplifiers can make reception worse, but the one that came in our present van works well.
There is nothing special about digital except that you do need coverage over the whole of the band. This is normal with any aerial sold for a motorhome or caravan.
The following members of MHF thanked safariboy for this posting
A magnetic aerial will be no good at all. You wither have an aluminium or fibre glass roof. The magnetic aerial also requires a good flat steel surface to give it a ground plane.
If you don't want to drill a hole in the roof then use an external aerial mounted on a demountable mast that can be clamped to your ladder. Then you can have a status amplifier inside the van. I use this arrangement and it works well. Just have to point the aerial in the right direction.
The following members of MHF thanked GerryD for this posting
Anyone have any experience of this type of TV aerial for Freeview reception?
Almost certainly a waste of time. Out LCD TV came with one, nothing.
ISTM, ATM "they" are not prepared to spend the money on transmitting a decent digital signal. We can see Winter Hill but can hardly get a decent picture with a proper TV aerial.
The following members of MHF thanked bhewart for this posting
Anyone have any experience of this type of TV aerial for Freeview reception?
Almost certainly a waste of time. Out LCD TV came with one, nothing.
ISTM, ATM "they" are not prepared to spend the money on transmitting a decent digital signal. We can see Winter Hill but can hardly get a decent picture with a proper TV aerial.
It is not a case of not spending money on transmitting a decent signal. All the time we still have analogue signals the digital transmitters can only run at a maximum of 10% power. You can have excellent digital TV tomorrow, just tell those people who have not yet bought a digital receiver why you switched off their analogue TV.
The following members of MHF thanked GerryD for this posting
Hi bhewart,
I'm not going to tell you how I know - you'll just have to trust me on this. There are issues with the transmission pattern from Winter Hill. Theoretically, it should be transmitting roughly equally in all directions, but it isn't. In certain directions there is nearly no signal. No consolation right now, but it should improve. I could tell you how I know this, but then I'd have to kill one of us!!
Rick
The following members of MHF thanked rickwiggans for this posting
We've found the stick aerials to be pretty poor. The best we found was the Thomson but I think they've stopped manufacturing them. Omni-directional aerials work fine when there's a good signal but a directional aerial is much better for weaker signals.
Of course the biggest problem with directional aerials is knowing which way to point the things!
Regards
Doug
The following members of MHF thanked falken for this posting
Only registered users can see links on our Forum Join Now or Login
I use one of these. Think I may have got it slightly cheaper than this at Tescos a couple of years ago but it is fab for van use. I usually use sky but if I cannot be bothered to put the satellite up or there are a lot of trees around I always get some sort of signal with this aerial - sometimes having to move it slightly for better picture on each channel but hey ho. Oddly enough, channel 5 seems to be the strongest most of the time. The sticky out antenna can be pointed in any direction as can the round bit. (on mine anyway).
This aerial has only ever been used in the van (we full time) and the only time I had an issue was when I was surrounded on 3 sides by huge great conifers (about 30 ft tall) so nothing worked .. not even the sun was getting through