UK Motorhome Information, Motorhome fun, American RV Forums, Articles, Reviews, Sales, Campsites
  Click here to Create an account Motorhome News RSS Feed ::  Home  ::  Subscriptions  ::  Your Account  ::  Forums ::  Directory::  Editorial  :: Motorhome Forums RSS Feed   Add to Google
Motorhome Facts :: View topic - Which refillable gas system?
 
Log in Register Forum FAQ Memberlist Search

BookmarksBookmarks  •  Watched TopicsWatched Topics  •  Arcade  •  Attachments  •  Buddy List  •  Ranks  •  Rules  •  Smilies List  •  Stats  •  
Forums Staff  • Medals  •  Courthouse
Google  
Sponsor this forum
>> Welcome to Motorhome Facts!

You are a Guest, please Join now to allow full access to the website and be part of our community. You can register by clicking the "Click Here to create an account" link at the top left of the page under our Logo


Latest News
Next Rally is @ Carsington Water
Nr Ashbourne,
Derbyshire on 23/10/2008 in Derbyshire
Motorhome Facts Forum Index -> Tech / Mech Chat -> LPG / Gas -> Which refillable gas system? Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
Post new topic  Reply to topic   Printer-friendly version co.mments Facebook del.icio.us digg blogmarks blinklist feed me links Furl Linkagogo Reddit Shadows Smarking simpy Spurl meneame technorati Yahoo Google :: :: View previous topic :: View next topic 
421488 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 9:08 am Thank this member for this postReply with quote
maddie Subscriber 14/05/2009 
 
Joined: Jan 04, 2006
Posts: 1456
Thanked 134 times in 131 posts

MH: iveco
Location: SOUTH YORKS

Medals: None
uk.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:0




bobandjane wrote:
Hi Terry I see you posted the same Ebay adaptor on Fun site as well.

Its not how good or careful you are at filling Calor bottles.

Its not safe to do it, you are doing it in a garage which is full of people, putting them at risk as well as yourself.

Thats why they put a shut of valve on refillable bottles. If the adaptors were legal we would all save some money and have them.

We all know that Calor charge a lot for Gas but you have to take into account they are delivering and collecting bottles, and TRAINING people to refill bottles, and if you buy a bottle you know they are not cheap, and then don't last forever.

With people like yourself filling with these adaptors. All that will happen in the end is NO ONE WILL BE ABLE TO FILL ANY BOTTLE.

Why take the risk, you spend all that money on a van so it cant be the money that stops you doing the job properly. Thanks Bob.

Hi Bob IT IS NOT ILEGAL to fill your bottles or use the adapter
Only registered users can see links on our Forum
Join Now or Login

see there.This is a very well respected company with v/good feedback on here.
My adapter fits stright onto the bottle without extra pipes or joins or 80 % full valves that can all go wrong,so why am I putting anyone at risk more than you Question or is it that you feel safer knowing you paid £450 as to my £30 Laughing
terry
edit the question was asked on both sites so I answered on both! Laughing

______________________________________________________________
When buying Remember, nothing can be said that cannot be written
View user's profile Send private message
421528 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 10:35 am Thank this member for this postReply with quote
bobandjane Subscriber 02/01/2009 
 
Joined: Dec 29, 2007
Posts: 290
Thanked 37 times in 36 posts

MH: Swift Kon-Tiki
Location: Suffolk

Medals: None
blank.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:2




Hi Terry. I think the adaptor you say about was for the plastic bottles with the window on the side with no 80% cut of valve. Also I see : So it is about the money.

Perhaps you are right because not many people agree with me, still I have said what I think and thats it. When someone has an accident and Calor get their way and we all end up going to distrubution depots to get gas, a lot of people will have lots to say then.
End of Rant. Thanks Bob.
View user's profile Send private message
421552 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 12:20 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
solentviews Subscriber 24/01/2009 
 
Joined: May 09, 2005
Posts: 691
Thanked 28 times in 27 posts

MH: Swift Kontiki 640
Location: Hampshire

Medals: None
england.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:12




Just one thought about Gas bottles versus tanks. The last time I looked which I admit was some time ago, you were not allowed through Eurotunnel with tanks but you are with bottles. If this has not changed could sway the decision.
Ian

______________________________________________________________
Over the hill, but proud of the climb!
View user's profile Send private message
421559 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 12:43 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
cabby Subscriber 07/01/2009 
 
Joined: May 14, 2005
Posts: 1791
Thanked 99 times in 98 posts

MH: Fleurette 73LJ
Location: south coast uk

Medals: None
uk.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:0




You are out of date, providing the tanks are not for the engine supply and only for domestic use and are able to be turned off, then they will let you travel. oh yes and they can only be 80% full and must show this.

cabby
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
421746 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 6:50 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
maddie Subscriber 14/05/2009 
 
Joined: Jan 04, 2006
Posts: 1456
Thanked 134 times in 131 posts

MH: iveco
Location: SOUTH YORKS

Medals: None
uk.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:0




bobandjane wrote:
Hi Terry. I think the adaptor you say about was for the plastic bottles with the window on the side with no 80% cut of valve. Also I see : So it is about the money.

Perhaps you are right because not many people agree with me, still I have said what I think and thats it. When someone has an accident and Calor get their way and we all end up going to distrubution depots to get gas, a lot of people will have lots to say then.
End of Rant. Thanks Bob.

Hi Bob if it was all about the moneyI think I can just about stretch to £450-500 and if not I could stay in for the weekend (away in the van that is)It comes down to simple logic-You put fuel pipe onto filler which then goes into a joint-flexi pipe-joint then tank,then reley on a flaot type device to cut off at 80% ? I put fuel pipe onto filler that goes straight into the bottle filll bottle to 7 ltrs (in theory I can put in 7.8 ltrs) turn off bottle valve.Exatly the same minus a few joints flexi pipe and float devise (do not try to tell me float devises do not go wrong I had too many old motor bikes to realise floats stick)Now who do you think has more to go wrong?Just because there are alternatives that everyone does not agree/understand with does not mean they do not work.I also have a diy Sog( £80)that cost me nothing more than a couple of cups of coffee,that also works.A diy spoiler that cost £3/4 instead of £30 because I did not know they sold them I made one instead.My tv is a normal (£150)240v / 12v jobby instead of the £350/ 400 one made purposesly for a caravan.My entire van is £10,000 instead of £30,000/40,000 (to get what I have got in)so yes it comes down to money in a way rather than bragging rights that I have got this! OH god I am bragging that I am A SKILLED handy person
Laughing
terry

______________________________________________________________
When buying Remember, nothing can be said that cannot be written
View user's profile Send private message
421796 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 8:03 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
oldenstar Subscriber 09/11/2009 
 
Joined: Nov 09, 2006
Posts: 566
Thanked 53 times in 53 posts

MH: Mooveo P608
Location: Devon

Medals: None
england.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:1




FWIW I think that if you have gone to the trouble (and expense) of having refillable bottles, either fitted or as a DIY job, then you might as well have the external filler.

Had my new van done by MTH last month (2 x 13Kg) and they have fitted the newer external filler-with this the UK connector is already in place so it is just a matter of one turn to remove the cap, wang on the pump gun and fill er up.

It looks really neat too. Mine is on the rear of the van, in the back bumper, as my gas cupboard is at the rear offside corner.

I already had one 13kg steel tank from my previous van, but as MTH only had the aluminium cylinders in stock I now have one of each.

Both cylinders fill automatically when refuelling, but I have a manual changeover so that I know when one runs out-I simply close off the empty cylinder and open the other valve. I use the aluminium first as these do not have a gauge, which the steel cylinders do.

Oh for the chance to start really using it. Crying or Very sad
Paul

______________________________________________________________
Forgotten, but not gone.
View user's profile Send private message
Gas system
421897 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 10:00 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
Rapide561 Subscriber 25/01/2009 
 
Joined: Oct 01, 2005
Posts: 9424
Thanked 616 times in 593 posts

MH: Swift Kon-tiki 679 low line - The "HMS Sheffield"
Location: Shrewsbury & Lake Garda

Medals: None
italy.gif

Status: Online
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:11




Hi

Irrespective of what type of system you purchase, my advice is to ask the installer to fill the system with lpg and test it for you. This way, any leaks will show up whilst you are with the installer, and not when you are alone at the refuelling point.

I speak from experience.

R

______________________________________________________________
Never been here before
I´m intrigued, I´m unsure
I´m searching for more
I´ve got something that´s all mine
I´ve got something that´s all mine
Take me somewhere I can breathe
I´ve got so much to see
This is where I want to be
In a place I can call mine
In a place I can call mine

View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail MSN Messenger Click Here to see my Motorhome Photo Gallery
421943 PostPosted: Tue May 06, 2008 10:56 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
Buzzer Subscriber 29/11/2008 
 
Joined: Oct 21, 2007
Posts: 23
Thanked 6 times in 6 posts

MH: Burstner Solano t615
Location: Essex

Medals: None
england.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:0




Hi everyone, many thanks to you all your much valued replies. After reading you posts and weighing it all up, I have decided to contact Richard at M.T.H. again, in regard to having a tank system fitted. If that is not a possible option for my particular MH, I shall probably go for the two 13 Kg aluminium bottles.

Thanks to all who have taken the time to reply, your input is much appreciated.

Happy trails Smile

Len

______________________________________________________________
"Work is the scourge of the drinking classes"-Oscar Wild
View user's profile Send private message
482322 PostPosted: Tue Sep 02, 2008 12:17 pm Thank this member for this postReply with quote
ActiveCampers Subscriber 12/10/2009 
 
Joined: Jun 17, 2005
Posts: 653
Thanked 40 times in 39 posts

MH: Horizons Unlimited Cavarno 2

Medals: None
blank.gif

Status: Offline
Found MHF how ?
Google
Events Attended:0




Resurecting this thread Smile

We currently carry 2x 6kg calor bottles, one connected in the (internal) gas locker; and one stored to swap over. The "spare" is the new calor lite with gas track.

We're doing lots of c. 6 week trips in Europe, and I am concerned how long the gas will last! As one bottle may almost be empty!

This thread mentions the dodgy eBay filler for calor bottles and also some refillable bottles.

So questions (contraversial!):-

The eBay type refiller for calor bottles:-
- If we had one of these, it would only be used on an empty bottle which would be removed from van for refilling. As such, the gas quantity would be known (12L) without risk of over filling (assuming you can stop it when you want).
- Who uses this? (Feel free to PM if you don't want to own up publically!)
- Is there a real risk associated with this? (I am aware some LPG people in Portugal will refill them for you anyway)
- Any factual rules/regs over this?
- Where would you practice a refil! Surprised

The other options seem to be refillable tanks available via MTH - and their website looks useful. Our issue is the gas locker can only take a single 6kg bottle which makes gaslow or a refillable bottle unusable as once its empty we're stuffed and its not worth filling a 6kg bottle when 1/2 full. OR IS IT?!

- The LPG underfloor tanks may be an option. Anyone here had them installed on a converted SWB transit? (where water tanks are slung under already!!
- Any view on these?


Thoughts welcome - only "thinking ahead" - if we can survive 6 weeks on a "bottle and a bit" then there is no need!!! (PS - had van 3 years, well over 100 nights away, and only on 2nd bottle!!! Mainly been on sites/hookup - but this will change on longer trips - so no benchmark yet)

Cheers

______________________________________________________________
Do you have a dream? If so - DO YOUR DREAM!!!
Only registered users can see links on our Forum
Join Now or Login


My research of hints/tips/bargains etc for motorhoming:
Only registered users can see links on our Forum
Join Now or Login


NOTE: Everything I post is my opinion, may or may not be correct so please check before making decisions based upon it. Corrections welcome, afterall we´re all here to learn.